Here is the argument for the traditional Good Friday crucifixion of Jesus.
Arguments for the Traditional Friday Crucifixion:
Jewish Time Reckoning: In the first century, any part of a day was often counted as a full day. Therefore, Friday (day 1), Saturday (day 2), and Sunday (day 3) fulfill the “three days” requirement
“Preparation Day” Definition: The Gospels identify the day of crucifixion as “Preparation Day” (John 19:31), which is commonly understood to mean the day before the Sabbath (Friday).”
Is it possible that Jesus was raised on Saturday evening (our time which would be Jewish first day of the week) instead of early Sunday morning? AI: “Yes, there is a prominent theological and chronological argument that Jesus was resurrected on Saturday evening (our time), rather than Sunday morning. This theory hinges on a strict, 72-hour interpretation of Jesus’ prophecy that he would be in the “heart of the earth” for “three days and three nights” (Matthew 12:40), combined with Jewish sunset-to-sunset timekeeping.
Here is the breakdown of that view based on the search results: The “Saturday Night” Argument
- Jewish Timekeeping: In the first century, days started at sunset, not midnight. Therefore, “the first day of the week” (Sunday) began at sunset on Saturday.
- The 72-Hour Count: To have 72 hours, three full nights (Wed, Thu, Fri) and three full days (Thu, Fri, Sat), Jesus would have needed to rise around sunset on Saturday—the very beginning of the first day of the week.
- Tomb Evidence: When the women arrived at the tomb early Sunday morning, it was already empty (John 20:1). This indicates the resurrection happened sometime before their arrival, potentially Saturday night.
- Wednesday Crucifixion: To align with a Saturday night resurrection, proponents believe Jesus was crucified on a Wednesday, not a Friday. In this scenario, Thursday was a “high day” Sabbath (Passover), Friday was a day of preparation, and Saturday was the regular weekly Sabbath.” In other words, there was a “high day” Sabbath in the last week that did not fall on the weekly Saturday Sabbath, and then there was the weekly Sabbath also mentioned which was on a Saturday That helps clear up what looks like a conradiction in the gospels.
BTW, if you use a strict 72 hour count then the 72 hours ends on Saturday evening at 6pm (Jewish time) and he had to be raised shortly after that. Otherwise, if he were raised, let us say, early Sunday morning our time, then he would be in the tomb more than 72 hours. That would be inconsistent with insisting that the 72 hours was exactly 72 hours. So this view would necessitate that Jesus was raised Saturday evening our time which would be the Jewish first day of the week.
Does it matter? Of course not, except for one thing. If Jesus meant 72 hours when he said “3 days and 3 nights” then he would have been mistaken if he was only in the tomb less than a full 72 hours. Some say that the 3 days and 3 nights could just mean part of 3 days and just two nights. I mean, when we say we are going to the beach for 3 days, that would only include 2 nights. If, as many believe, Jesus was crucified on Friday, he would only be in the tomb a couple of hours on Friday before 6pm Saturday began, and all day Saturday, and then several hours on Sunday: thus parts of 3 days and 2 full nights. The Jewish use of day and night is more specific than that. When the terms day and night are used together, it always refers to a 12 hour day and a 12 hour night (as in Genesis on day 1). So the full 72 hours in the tomb makes more sense.
All this is based on Jesus being raised on the first day of the week (Jewish time). Yes the women came to the tomb early on Sunday, the first day of the week, but it doesn’t say that he was raised on Sunday morning our time. Luke 24:1 the women came on the first day of the week to the tomb. Jesus is walking and talking with the 2 men on the road to Emmaus that same day. Then in 24:21 one of the men said that “it is now (Sunday) the third day since these things (i.e. the trial and crucifixion of Jesus) happened.” Does he mean that Sunday was the 3rd day since Jesus was crucified or does he meant that on that Sunday 3 full days that had passed since Jesus was crucified or does he mean that it was the 3rd day since the sealing of the tomb which happened probably on the day after the crucifixion. A lot hinges on how to interpret what the man said .
Many believe that Sunday was indeed the 3rd day since he was crucified, which is actually what 24:21 says. If so, that gives credibility to the view that Jesus was crucified on Good Friday. Here is that view:
AI: “In Luke 24:21, the first day of the week (Sunday) is considered the “third day” because of inclusive reckoning, a common first-century Jewish idiom where any part of a day is counted as a full day. Crucifixion on Friday our time (Day 1), burial on Saturday our time (Day 2), and resurrection Sunday morning our time (Day 3) constitutes three days. That would be the parts of 3 days and 2 full nights view.
How the 3rd Day Calculation Works: This view used Roman time and our time with a day beginning at. 12 am.
- Day 1 (Friday): Jesus was crucified and buried before sunset. This portion of Friday counts as the first day.
- Day 2 (Saturday/Sabbath): Jesus remained in the tomb for the entirety of Saturday.
- Day 3 (Sunday): Jesus rose early in the morning, making Sunday the third day of the sequence.
This inclusive method meant that the partial time on Friday, the whole day of Saturday, and the early hours of Sunday were recognized together as three days, rather than a strict 72-hour period. The disciples in Luke 24:21 were counting Sunday as the third day since the events of Friday.” That view makes sense also if it doesn’t have to be a full 72 hours.
Using this same inclusive method, some have even argued that Jesus was crucified on Thursday our time before 6 pm, and, using our time, thus was in the tomb Thur, Fri, and Sat nights and that would mean he was only in the tomb 2 full days (Friday and Saturday our time) but that Sunday was the third day since his death, which is what the man on the road said (Luke 24:21). That view makes more sense that the crucified on Good Friday view to me, but it still would mean that he was not in the tomb a full 72 hours, (instead, 3 full nights and parts of 3 days). Here is that view:
AI: “Yes, it is historically and biblically possible that Jesus was crucified on a Thursday rather than a Friday. This view argues that a Thursday crucifixion provides a full 72 hours (“three days and three nights”) to fit the “sign of Jonah” prophecy (Matthew 12:40), allowing for a Thursday burial and a Sunday resurrection.
Key Arguments for a Thursday Crucifixion:
- Three Full Days and Nights: A Thursday death allows for three full nights (Thursday/Fri, Fri/Sat, Sat/Sun) in the tomb before rising on Sunday, addressing the limitation of a Friday crucifixion, which only covers two nights.
- Two Sabbaths Theory: Proponents argue that a “special Sabbath” (First Day of Passover) occurred on Friday, followed by the regular Saturday Sabbath. The women could have purchased spices on Friday in between the two Sabbaths.
- Timing of Passover: A Thursday crucifixion aligns with the view that Jesus was killed at the same time the Passover lambs were being prepared on Nisan 14.
Back to the crucified on Wed Jewish time before Thursday Jewish time began at 6pm
If Jesus was raided shortly after Jewish first day of the week began at 6pm Saturday Jewish time, then start there and back up 72 full hours. That would take you back to crucifixion on Wednesday Jewish time, in the tomb that night Thursday night Jewish time, Thursday day, Friday night, Friday day, Saturday night, Saturday day (all Jewish times) which be right at 72 full hours in the tomb. But how would we reconcile that the man in Luke 24 said that Sunday was only the 3rd day since the crucifixion. Some interpretations suggest that the “third day” refers not to the crucifixion itself, but to the finalization of the sealing of the tomb (which happened probably on the morning after he was crucified). So if that is so, then backing 3 days from Sunday would be from Friday Jewish time, Saturday Jewish time, and then Sunday the 3rd day since the sealing of the tomb on Thursday Jewish time.
I’m still not sure which view to take? What about you? The main thing is that he was crucified for our sins, buried, and raised on the 3rd day. But the timing of all that is debated a lot, and you can see why. After writing this article, I remembered why I have not spent much time in the past studying this topic. Every time I do, I can’t come up with a definitive view. The fact that Jesus specified 3 days and 3 nights does make me want to study it more closely!
Just something to think about as we celebrate the resurrection of Jesus.


